projected view

Visual Memory

When images are organized in a sequence each one breathes meaning into the other. Social media and online historical photo databases have made it popular to pluck a single image, identified through a subject search, and interpret it according to the dictates of one historical watershed or another. I took the opposite approach to explore the William James City of Toronto Archives lantern slide collection (Series 2119). Watching the fluid movement of thousands of images float by on the screen I attempted to identify the mentality of the man behind the lens and piece together the thinking behind his organization of images into sets.

89.22 James looking at bust 89.22 James looking at bust (for post on photographer’s fascination with phrenology click here)

In a recent post I discussed how late in his career artist George A. Reid organized his photos, sketches and press clippings into a scrapbook.  Similarly, photographer William James incorporated his earlier photographs into a collection of lantern slides with newer images taken in the 1920’s. These two personal visual archives served to chart their creative output and offered them an opportunity to arrange their records in a publicly meaningful way.

William James Sr. binding lantern slides 1921

However, the arrangement that James’ created for his lantern slides is not intact.  His son Norm James and grand-daughter Mary-Lou Griffin owned the collection before it was purchased by the Archives in 1976. Christopher Hume in William James Toronto Views: Lantern Slides from 1906 to 1939, quotes Griffin on how the collection became disorganized.

It was stuffed in boxes, bags and envelopes… [and] sat in my parents’ basement for years and years. Some of the negatives were stuck together and were in bad shape. During the mid-1960s, I spent nearly three years going through this stuff. People used to call my dad all the time to see if he had a picture of this or that. So that’s why we numbered each print, each one.

Because the fragile glass slides were stored in wooden boxes they retain some vestige of their original organization into sets. The thematic unity of sets 80 (to view on Flickr click here) and 85-86 illustrating the work of the British Welcome League is one example.  Nevertheless, the storage chaos means that the lantern slide collection contains many incongruous combinations of images that make James’ interpretations difficult to reconstruct.  The captions, moreover, are an amalgam of original information left by James with additions based on the anecdotal recollections (see example below) of his son and grand-daughter along with supplementary information from Archives staff.

57.26 child yawning (at a James slide show no doubt) 57.26 child yawning (at a James slide show no doubt)

James 80.39 ad colour 80.39 ad for James

First and foremost, the slide lectures were an opportunity for James to display both his ability as a photographer and the range of his work.  His goal was to record Ontario life, with a focus on Toronto, through views of its landscapes and social, industrial and commercial life.  In preparing for his lectures (many which could have been merely planned and not delivered) James used his older photographs combined with new images to illustrate selected topics of public interest. The clustering of slides relating to Phrenology, Prehistoric man and Ethnology among different sets in the collection reflects a climate of debate around race and immigration that was both academic and political.

Sir Bertram Windle’s Extension Education Lectures

 Drawn by advance publicity, one thousand people turned up at the first of Sir Bertram Windle’s lectures in January 1920. The subject, “Pre-history in the British Isles”, was explored over twelve lectures on successive Friday afternoons.  Offered free of charge as a University of Toronto Extension Course, they proved a hit, drawing the same large number each week.

University of Toronto Extension Courses, Globe Dec. 30, 1922 p.2 Globe Dec. 30, 1922

Professor of Anthropology at St. Michael’s College and lecturer on Ethnology from 1919 until his death ten years later, Windle’s depth of culture enabled him to draw vivid connections between the history of man and art, folklore and literature. “The lectures are interesting, instructive and by no means devoid of humor and the enjoyment of them are increased by the accompanying lantern slides which have been made from excellent photographs.”  Globe Nov.8, 1922 p.16

Free Lectures on Ethnology, Globe, Nov. 8, 1922 p16aFree Lectures on Ethnology, Globe, Nov. 8, 1922 p16 program  Globe, Nov. 8, 1922

46.10 Short Negroid woman of Lawall 46.10 Short Negroid woman of Lawall

46.11 Man of the late Neolithic period 46.11 Man of the late Neolithic period

46.12 Old man, Cro-magnon period 46.12 Old man, Cro-magnon period

46.13 Dyak girl in full tribal dress 46.13 Dyak girl in full tribal dress

59.50 Neanderthal man 59.50 Neanderthal man

The James’ lantern slides made from printed reproductions of ethnological subjects and museum busts reflect the interest stirred up by the annual lecture series. Windle’s presentations likely inspired the photographer to develop sets on particular topics that required him to supplement his own his photographs with published illustrations from various sources.  Possibly he developed one for copy-cat lectures; so popular were Windle’s lectures that local daily, The Telegram published the full text of each.

Ethnic Theatre

Interest in other cultures, at the level of the picture press was expressed typically in the July 3, 1921 Toronto Star Weekly in the portrait of the San Francisco dancer who was to perform her “Sensational Indian Dance” with the Ziegfield Follies. Above the dancer appears a cameo of “Princess Fatima, Sultana of Kabul, Afghanistan, Now in the United States En Route to England with Her Three Sons who will Enter College There. She Wears a Jewel in Her Nose.”

Toronto Star Weekly July 3, 1921 p2 Click on image to enlarge

This type of costume-drama ethnology had a tenacious hold on the popular imagination. Working within the tradition, James’ photographs of a North American aboriginal man in both his traditional and European clothing dramatized contrary cultures embodied in one individual. The bare chested tattoo portrait of Charlie White, pioneer Toronto tattoo artist, is another example of ethnological illustration/circus side-show subject attractive to photographer and news readers.

21.17 Indian in Indian garb 21.17 Indian in Indian garb

21.18 same indian in Western garb 21.18 same Indian in Western garb

Sir Bertram Windle’s lectures outlined the global breadth and historical depth of culture. They sensitized many Torontonians to the common experiences and values that united humanity.  From the podium Windle asserted that the theory of human evolution was no longer theory but fact. The academic brought cutting-edge thinking to a conservative, colonial city.

The principle of cultural relativism and embrace of pluralism did not penetrate far. At the same time that the lectures were taking place, private agencies and public organizations were pressing the government for a policy to exclude particular kinds of immigrants from entering the country.

Rejecting Undesirables and Hand-picking Immigrants

???????????????????????????????  70.23 Strikers with signs locked out by T. Eaton Co.

Public pressure based on the labour unrest and unemployment of the post-war years pushed the Dominion government to become more hard-line on who should be admitted into Canada. The dominant rhetoric, as reflected in the Globe took the form of concern over the risk to public welfare from those who had refused or were unable to assimilate.

 Occurrences in Canada during the war revealed on a number of occasions the shortcomings of the immigration policies of bygone years. Canada should not again, … permit the herding together of non-English-speaking Europeans who follow a number of the objectionable customs and usages of the lands whence they come. Many of these ways are unsuitable to this country, some are a menace to the health of those who practise them as well as to the people around them, while others are dangerous to the whole community.” “It is evident that the sources and volume of immigration must be limited by the possibilities of Canadianizing the newcomers.”  Globe Jan. 23, 19, 1920

A report from New York three weeks later reported that thirty immigrants from Malta, bound for Canada, were stopped at Ellis Island by Canadian authorities and sent back. The immigration official stated, “Owing to labor conditions in Canada we have been instructed to enforce the exclusion law to the letter. … Most of the aliens are now coming from Southern Europe and we are sending a great many of them back. We are handpicking the immigrants for Canada now.” Globe Feb. 19, p7

Canada to Reject All Undesirables, Globe, Feb. 19, 1920 p7a

“Firmly Established On the Soil”

In the autumn of 1922 the Dominion government announced a new immigration policy and land settlement scheme. The objective was, “… to promote immigration by the careful selection of agricultural workers in the countries of origin and by proper direction of the newcomers in Canada so that they will become firmly established on the soil.” Globe Sept. 11, 1922

Shortly after, under contract to the provincial government, William James packed a suitcase full of wooden boxed slide sets and set off to lure “the right kind of people” to rural Canada.

68.13 Map of Ontario 68.13 Map of Ontario

Among the least known of James’ photographs are his rural landscapes and documentation of southern Ontario farms and livestock.  Many of his countryside views were part of his stock in trade for the local dailies, however others show a stronger documentary focus. These displayed the details of farm life required for his illustrated lectures to prospective farmers. Most of them, concentrated largely in set 44, can be viewed by clicking here.

44.51 Large tree by country roadside 44.51 Large tree by country roadside

44.20 perhaps prize Bull 44.20 prize? Bull

Alert to the commercial  opportunities of the tour, James introduced himself as a potential agent of photography supplies to London dealers.

112.26 112.26

He also took copious photos for future lantern slide illustrated travelogues. Set 112 features images of England and Germany and incorporates such printed material as press clippings, ticket stubs and German Entry Visa.

112.65  Press report of Wm. James visit to Edinburgh  112.65 Press report of Wm. James visit to Edinburgh

The other form of labour in short supply back in Toronto was female domestic servants. James’ documentation of the city’s amenities and lively social scene may have encouraged young single women to immigrate.

Recent revisions to the immigration policy demanded all mechanic, artisan and labor class immigrants to have $250 in savings and proof of transportation to his destination. (Globe Dec. 1, 1920) On his return to Toronto James criticized the policy, pointing out that those who had the type of savings required as a condition of immigration preferred to stay home. There was, he insisted, an untapped source of ideal immigrants in the Hebrides Islands where the fish stocks were depleted leaving many in dire straits.

People of Hebrides Suited to Canada, Globe, Feb. 23, 1923 p15aPeople of Hebrides Suited to Canada, Globe, Feb. 23, 1923 p15b People of Hebrides Suited to Canada, Globe, Feb. 23, 1923 p15c  Globe, Feb. 23, 1923

500 Hebrideans Sail for Dominion Today, Star, April 21 1923 p1  Star, April 21 1923

News In Pictures, The Globe, May 8, 1923 p12  Globe, May 8, 1923

??????????????????????????????? 42.46 Canadian flag

Join me tomorrow to celebrate a year of market square at The Stop’s Wychwood Barns Farmers’ Market. To see a retrospective slide show of the project on Flikr click here.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s